Skip to main content
23000 Get Directions
DEAL ENDED
Get notified when Shake Shack Theater District posts a new deal
No spam — just a heads up when they post again.
Shake Shack Milkshake Duo — Just $29 (Reg. $46)
1 / 15
Shake Shack Theater District
Two legendary shakes, two straws, and a sip of NYC — all for just $29.
4.4(14,947)
on the outskirts of Midtown South
The Shake That Started It All
Shake Shack's premium milkshakes have a cult following for good reason — hand-spun from real frozen custard in flavors that range from classic vanilla to the legendary peanut butter that customers swear is "to die for." Whether you're fueling up before a Broadway show or winding down after midnight in Times Square, this is the indulgent, creamy treat that keeps New Yorkers coming back. Grab a friend, pick your flavors, and find out what all the fuss is about.
$29Reg. $46
37% OFF
The Vibe
What visitors love about this place
27 people agreed
“This location in the heart of Times Square is super busy but service is handled fairly quick. I've tried Shake Shack plenty of times almost everywhere! Consistently great burgers, always way to go”
20 agreed
“Sometimes you don't want a rich and oversized restaurant burger late at night, you just need a smaller snack burger to ensure an easy sleep. Shake Shack is your burger joint made just for that.”
2 people agreed
“Their burgers were worth the long line and their peanut butter shake is to die for. I cannot wait for Shake Shack to come to the West Coast.”
2 agreed
“Danny Meyer's billion dollar burger chain reaches its apex at the The Times Square location for a very simple reason: It's the only one that's open until midnight.”
1 agreed
“The chicken sandwich is a must. I hope it stays forever. I love the shack stack. Those delicious fried portobello tops and that sauce are a match made in heaven.”
27 people agreed
“This location in the heart of Times Square is super busy but service is handled fairly quick. I've tried Shake Shack plenty of times almost everywhere! Consistently great burgers, always way to go”
20 agreed
“Sometimes you don't want a rich and oversized restaurant burger late at night, you just need a smaller snack burger to ensure an easy sleep. Shake Shack is your burger joint made just for that.”
2 people agreed
“Their burgers were worth the long line and their peanut butter shake is to die for. I cannot wait for Shake Shack to come to the West Coast.”
2 agreed
“Danny Meyer's billion dollar burger chain reaches its apex at the The Times Square location for a very simple reason: It's the only one that's open until midnight.”
1 agreed
“The chicken sandwich is a must. I hope it stays forever. I love the shack stack. Those delicious fried portobello tops and that sauce are a match made in heaven.”
Powered by Foursquare
Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps
4.4
14,947 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
D
DCApr 2026
Had an amazing experience at Shake Shack! The male server who delivered our burgers was incredibly energetic and full of smiles. He served our food swiftly and diligently, explaining everything clearly, all while keeping a positive, lively vibe throughout the restaurant. He really set the tone for the whole place, making it feel welcoming and well managed, and the cleanliness of the tables and surroundings was noticeable too. Truly a standout example of excellent service, definitely deserves praise!
Google Maps
M
Michele GroveApr 2026
Delicious burgers and milkshakes. Friendly service. Reasonable prices. Gets very crowded and hard to find a table to sit at. Does have some counters to stand up and eat also. Has a restroom for customers. Free cups of water.
Google Maps
M
Maryna StupakApr 2026
🍔 Quick, tasty, and full of little surprises! We stopped by Shake Shack in the Theater District for a casual dinner — and it turned out to be a really great choice. The service was fast, and what’s nice is that they actually bring the food right to your table, which makes the experience more relaxed and enjoyable. 🙌 I ordered one of their classic burgers and was surprised by a fun little twist — crispy fried pickles in batter! 🥒✨ It was something different and added a nice crunch to the meal. Everything was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. There’s plenty of seating, which is a big plus in this area, and it didn’t feel cramped or noisy even during the dinner rush. Tables were clean, and the vibe was welcoming. ✅ Great for a quick bite before or after a Broadway show ✅ Fun menu twists (fried pickles, yes please!) ✅ Enough space to sit down and enjoy your meal If you’re in Midtown and need a fast, delicious, and hassle-free dinner — I definitely recommend this location of Shake Shack! 🍟🍔
Google Maps
F
Franny BaeApr 2026
Love their burgers! I always get them well done. They are nice and juicy and the best with lettuce tomato and onions. My baby had a mix of ice cream chocolate and vanilla with Oreo topping and he loved it. The staff was very accommodating attentive and friendly.
Google Maps
M
MerryheartApr 2026
Stopped by Shake Shack Theatre Street, NYC for a late-night bite, and even at 10 PM, the place was packed—a testament to its popularity, but also a reminder that you might need to wait for a table. Ambience was nothing special, just your typical fast-casual setup, but the food made up for it. Tried the Truffle Burger, and it delivered-tender, juicy patties with deep, rich flavors that didn't disappoint. The milkshake? A standout! Fragrant, creamy, and indulgent without feeling too heavy. Bonus points for table delivery, which made the experience smoother. If you don't mind the crowd, it's a solid spot for a satisfying, late-night burger fix. Would I return? Yes, if I am looking for a quick meal.
Google Maps
D
DCApr 2026
Had an amazing experience at Shake Shack! The male server who delivered our burgers was incredibly energetic and full of smiles. He served our food swiftly and diligently, explaining everything clearly, all while keeping a positive, lively vibe throughout the restaurant. He really set the tone for the whole place, making it feel welcoming and well managed, and the cleanliness of the tables and surroundings was noticeable too. Truly a standout example of excellent service, definitely deserves praise!
Google Maps
M
Michele GroveApr 2026
Delicious burgers and milkshakes. Friendly service. Reasonable prices. Gets very crowded and hard to find a table to sit at. Does have some counters to stand up and eat also. Has a restroom for customers. Free cups of water.
Google Maps
M
Maryna StupakApr 2026
🍔 Quick, tasty, and full of little surprises! We stopped by Shake Shack in the Theater District for a casual dinner — and it turned out to be a really great choice. The service was fast, and what’s nice is that they actually bring the food right to your table, which makes the experience more relaxed and enjoyable. 🙌 I ordered one of their classic burgers and was surprised by a fun little twist — crispy fried pickles in batter! 🥒✨ It was something different and added a nice crunch to the meal. Everything was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. There’s plenty of seating, which is a big plus in this area, and it didn’t feel cramped or noisy even during the dinner rush. Tables were clean, and the vibe was welcoming. ✅ Great for a quick bite before or after a Broadway show ✅ Fun menu twists (fried pickles, yes please!) ✅ Enough space to sit down and enjoy your meal If you’re in Midtown and need a fast, delicious, and hassle-free dinner — I definitely recommend this location of Shake Shack! 🍟🍔
Google Maps
F
Franny BaeApr 2026
Love their burgers! I always get them well done. They are nice and juicy and the best with lettuce tomato and onions. My baby had a mix of ice cream chocolate and vanilla with Oreo topping and he loved it. The staff was very accommodating attentive and friendly.
Google Maps
M
MerryheartApr 2026
Stopped by Shake Shack Theatre Street, NYC for a late-night bite, and even at 10 PM, the place was packed—a testament to its popularity, but also a reminder that you might need to wait for a table. Ambience was nothing special, just your typical fast-casual setup, but the food made up for it. Tried the Truffle Burger, and it delivered-tender, juicy patties with deep, rich flavors that didn't disappoint. The milkshake? A standout! Fragrant, creamy, and indulgent without feeling too heavy. Bonus points for table delivery, which made the experience smoother. If you don't mind the crowd, it's a solid spot for a satisfying, late-night burger fix. Would I return? Yes, if I am looking for a quick meal.
Google Maps
Location
Shake Shack Theater District
Address
691 8th AvenueNew York, New York 10036
Hours
Phone
(646) 435-0135Locating address…
$29$46